Sears CEO pushes new plan to avoid bankruptcy
ESL Investments proposes plan to prevent Chapter 11.
With a big debt payment coming due, Eddie Lampert, the chairman, CEO and biggest shareholder and creditor of Sears Holdings Corp., is making his biggest push to date to save the beleagured company from filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection.
ESL Investments, the hedge fund run by Lampert, has come up with a plan that would essentially translate into a wholesale financial restructuring of the company but without a Chapter 11 filing. It would significantly reduce the struggling retailer’s $5.6 billion debt load, cutting it by nearly 80%. The plan, outlined in a securities filing made by ESL on September 24, include selling off many of Sears’ remaining stores and asking lenders to exchange their loans for equity stakes in the retailer.
In the filing, ESL warns that Sears is facing “significant near-term liquidity constraints,” with $134 million in debt coming due in October.
Under the ESL proposal, Sears would sell about $1.5 billion worth of real estate, much of which the retailer has used in recent years as collateral to generate liquidity, and about $1.75 billion other assets, including Sears’ Kenmore appliance brand, which ESL first proposed buying back in the spring. Some of the stores would be leased back to Sears, the filing said.
“Sears must act immediately to have sufficient runway to continue its transformation,” ESL said in its proposal.
Neil Saunders, managing director of GlobalData Retail, said that the new ESL proposal would indeed help Sears pay down pay down some of its enormous debt and provide it with a “buffer” of liquidity. But it does not get to the root of Sears’ problems.
“As usual, Sears is focusing on financial maneuvers and missing the wider point that sales remain on a downward trajectory. Saunders said. “In our view, this is because both Sears and Kmart are suffering from chronic underinvestment and a lack of clarity in terms of their proposition. Even in a strong consumer economy, customers are still drifting away to other brands and retailers.”
In a statement, Sears said it had received ESL’s proposal and the board had asked its legal and financial advisers to work closely with ESL and other stakeholders to pursue “liability management transactions” similar to what ESL has proposed. Sears said any move would require approval of its advisers and independent board members.
“There can be no assurance that any transaction will be consummated or on what terms any transaction may occur,” Sears stated.
HBSDealer Stock Watch: Monday’s Blues
|Hardware and building supply stocks had a rough day on Wall Street Monday.|
|BLDR (Builders FS)||15.45||-1.47%|
|BMCH (BMC Stock)||20.55||-1.44%|
|CENT (Central Garden)||38.28||-2.45%|
|DE (Deere & Co.)||151.55||-0.82%|
|HD (Home Depot)||207.99||-2.07%|
|LL (Lumber Liquidators)||17.32||-2.37%|
|SMG (Scotts Miracle-Gro)||78.15||-0.88%|
|TSCO (Tractor Supply)||90.55||+0.63%|
|UFPI (Universal Forest)||35.14||-1.07%|
Poll Question: Sears’ financial future
The company hopes to avoid the “B” word. But can it?
Sears Holdings in recent years has been one of the most talked about retailers in American, and for many of the wrong reasons. Store closings and poor financial results have regularly sparked doom-and-gloom headlines.
And those headlines in the financial press are back, and many are predicting the B-word: “bankruptcy.” But the company is hoping to hold it off with a restructuring of debt and a sale of more property.
Time will tell. What will it tell? That’s this week’s HBSDealer poll question: Can Sears avoid bankruptcy in your opinion?
Take the poll on the right side of the screen (or scroll down your handheld device). Or, tell us your thoughts on Sears future here. We invite your comments.