Lumber Liquidators is under fire again over charges that its products contain illegal levels of formaldehyde after Global Community Monitor and Sunshine Park LLC filed a lawsuit in California state court July 23.
According to allegations by the Global Community Monitor, the retailer's Chinese-made flooring was found in independent lab tests to emit considerably more formaldehyde than the level that requires cancer warnings under California law. More than 50 tests of the Chinese-made laminate flooring were conducted using various testing methods and sample batches, with results pointing to an average exposure level that's over 100 times the legal limit for selling without a warning label.
"The levels of formaldehyde our tests found in Lumber Liquidators' laminate flooring are astounding and alarming," said Denny Larson, executive director of Global Community Monitor. "It's unconscionable that Lumber Liquidators would sell this product to customers to install in their homes without informing families of the potential health risks involved, especially since they make a point of bragging about how environmentally safe it is."
If true, these allegations would place Lumber Liquidators under violation of California's Proposition 65, which requires potentially cancer-causing products to carry a warning label, according to established limits for chemical levels.
Lumber Liquidators issued a July 23 statement denying these claims, however, reaffirming its commitment to upholding environmental standards and independently testing its products to ensure compliance.
“The allegations in this lawsuit concerning our product are simply flat-out false," read the statement. "Our product meets relevant environmental standards and undergoes rigorous, independent, third-party testing. More specifically, our internal testing and that conducted by third parties concluded that product levels fell well below the Proposition 65 “safe harbor” limits."
Lumber Liquidators added that it strives to maintain transparency about its quality control processes, providing Proposition 65 notices on customer invoices and in-store signage.
"In short, all of our flooring meets the highest quality and environmental standards – that’s why we sell it, that’s why we use it in our own homes, and that’s why we are a market leader," continued the retailer. "We will not let factually inaccurate and legally flawed lawsuits filed by a party with a clear financial motive influence our approach to our business or our customers.”
The company has had a spate of run-ins with environmental advocacy groups and the U.S. authorities in recent years, including an investigation following Seeking Alpha analyst Xuhua Zhou's report last June that it was selling products containing illegal levels of formaldehyde.
Last October, feds descended on Lumber Liquidators' Toano, Virginia headquarters after an environmental advocacy group issued a report that the retailer had been purchasing wood from protected forests in Far East Russia through a Chinese supplier, placing it in violation of the Lacey Act.
Lumber Liquidators has since taken steps to buff up its compliance team, hiring a new chief compliance and sustainability officer in February and a director global product compliance and director global trade and customs compliance in June.